by Nicci Gerrard
Missing Persons is a story about an English family who live in East Anglia: Isabel is a primary-school teacher, Felix an academic at the nearby university, and their three children are growing up. The middle child, Johnny (never called John) is the only one of the three who seems problem-free: as the novel opens his parents take him to start his university degree course in Sheffield. After a few weeks, Johnny ceases all communication and vanishes.
The novel tells the story of the next seven years in the lives of the remaining family members. A long section of 200 pages is devoted to Isabel’s reactions in the days and weeks immediately following the disappearance, including her perceptions of her own childhood family and of various friends of hers and of Johnny’s. Although movingly depicted, there are far too many details of cooking and nurturing to sustain this number of pages. The second half of the novel, narrated from various perspectives, is in some ways more engaging, as fewer pages proportionately are given to each year since the disappearance. But even though the author provides many telling vignettes, the narrative as a whole tends to skate over the surface rather than getting to grips with the issues or the characters.
As ever with Nicci Gerrard, this book is readable and is a telling intimate portrait of family life and the pains of growing up. The parents and siblings are forced to adapt to the loss of Johnny, but essentially stay the same – particularly in the case of Isabel, a rather overwhelmingly domesticated woman (her cooking is frankly obsessive) who seems to swamp her offspring with anxiety and a striving for a perfect family image. Her personality makes it easy to see how a child might feel claustrophobic or find it hard to break away independently. Although there is much to like about this book, in the end I found it frustratingly superficial in its failure to provide real insight into motivation and cause.
When Nicci Gerrard writes crime novels with Sean French in the Nicci French persona, the mystery or thriller plot provides an impetus for the story. In Missing Persons, the story itself becomes the details – of Isobel’s relationships with her brother, her seeking out of the man who painted her mother (who died when she was nine), Felix’s breakdown, weddings and funerals, and so on. Although the novel is undoubtedly sincere, these descriptions in themselves do not add up to enough. A braver investigation into Johnny’s story or a different outcome for the family dynamics in the final section, for example, could have provided the book with some much-needed edge and purpose.
I received this book free from the Amazon Vine programme
We Love this Book: short review of this novel.
YouTube: Nicci Gerrard talks about the novel.
Observer: Nicci Gerrard on “empty nest” syndrome, an article published to coincide with Missing Children’s day (25 May).
Best crime books: synopsis of this book and the other novels written by Nicci Gerrard as sole author (all of which I’ve read, so I know they are not crime novels!).
Interesting. As is it’s not a thriller, I wonder if we find out what happened to Johnny at the end of the book. Your review suggests not which makes it, as you say, more a study of the impact of a disappearance on a family. I think I will read this sometime – it reminds me a little of Julie Myerson.
Yes, it is very readable, Sarah. I liked most of Nicci Gerrard’s standalones, my favourite is Solace (2005), followed by Things We Knew Were True (2003).
I have only read one book by Julie Myerson (plus many of her newspaper articles when she wrote for the paper I read daily), and I can say that Nicci Gerrard is, in my view, much better based on that one comparison.
Maxine – As ever, an excellent review, for which thanks. This really does seem more a study of personality and relationships than it does a crime/mystery novel where there is more attention to the investigation. I agree with you that stories where we really see a good look at the impact of a tragedy – admitting the elephant’s in the room, so to speak – can be very moving. That said though, this sounds like an interesting group of characters and a solid story.
Thanks, Margot. She had decided not to write a literary novel, it seems, which really would delve in to it all in some way or other, but to stick with the popular level — which is fine, but without a crime plot or something to give it a bit of oomph, one was left with a bit of a “women’s commercial fiction aka chick lit” feel to it. Though I don’t read that genre, and if I did I’d probably find this a top-end example of it – definitely shying away from some of the real issues that could have been addressed.
Sounds interesting. I liked Sarah’s comment about not finding out what happens in the end – I read the Winter House & it felt as if there was enough tension building for “something to happen” but it didn’t. Despite that I enjoyed the Winter House & will add this to the TBR list!
Thanks, Suzigun. I found The Winter House too harrowing and grim, but as usual with Nicci Gerrard, well-written and readable. This one is much lighter.
Pingback: Missing Persons by Nicci Gerrad | Petrona Book Reviews archive
Pingback: June reading report and book of the month | Petrona