Book review: Crossbones Yard by Kate Rhodes

Crossbones Yard
by Kate Rhodes
Mullholland Press, 2012
Alice Quentin #1

Young psychologist Alice Quentin, struggling with a massive workload at Guy’s, a large London hospital, is called on by DCI Don Burns of the Southwark police to advise on a case. Part of Alice’s job is to provide professional input to police investigations if a mental-health angle is involved. She is told that a woman has been killed in a horrific way. The method and location of the murder are strongly reminiscent of a ghastly earlier case in which a Fred and Rosemary West-type couple (the wife coloured by a strong shade of Myra Hindley) were convicted of torturing and killing several young women lodging in their house over a period of years.

Burns is now puzzled by how the murderer could have known details about the earlier deaths that were kept from the general public. Alice is struck by her own physical similarity to the new victim. Not only that, but the method of death is that the criminals enclosed the victims in a box and beat them up before stabbing them – which, apart from the stabbing, is exactly what happened to Alice as a child, the abuser being her father.

Although one might think that this is one coincidence too many, the author does not harp on too much about these synergies but instead shifts the focus to Alice’s daily life and her various friends and neighbours – controlling boyfriend Sean, kooky wannabe actress Lola, and her schizophrenic, drug-addicted brother Will. The way in which Alice’s horrific childhood has affected her as well as her mother and brother is a recurring theme in the book, as the three family members remain scarred by their memories. Soon another woman is killed and Alice begins to receive threatening letters and worse.

Alice pursues her own investigations, interviewing the “Rosemary/Myra” character in prison as well as various meetings with a mentally ill man who lived with the infamous couple during their killing spree, who may know something. Although by now Alice is staying in a hotel under 24-hour police protection, it seems to be a race to solve the case before the attacker closes in on her.

There are three obvious candidates for the villain, and the final unveiling leaves one with the feeling that it could just as easily have been any of them. Yet despite the standard plot, the genre clichés, several holes and the questionable borrowing of details from a real-life case, Crossbones Yard is a page-turner with an interesting heroine and a strong sense of its London location — a promising debut novel.

I received this book free in the Amazon Vine programme.

Other reviews of Crossbones Yard: Books and Writers and Random Jottings.

Shotsmag Confidential: post by the author about the setting for Crossbones Yard – fascinating local history.

10 thoughts on “Book review: Crossbones Yard by Kate Rhodes

  1. Maxine – Thank you for a candid, thoughtful review. It’s interesting that you would mention the setting because that’s what got my attention. It does sound like an interesting debut and I will probably read it at some point. I’m not sure I’m ready just now for another protagonist with a horrible past who’s up against a nasty killer of young women, to be honest…

    • There are rather a lot of predictable cliches in this, Margot, it is true — but at least it isn’t gruesome and the London history is done well. Pity I read it so soon after Tuesday’s Gone by Nicci French as they also cover London history (though not the Crossbones yard area) & are more evocative, I think.

  2. Maxine –

    Wow, a February, 2013 release for the US of A! I guess they don’t see this as a big Christmas item. Ken

  3. The background to this story sounds a bit rough. I think I’ll hold off on reading it.
    Wanted to reaffirm the recommendations of William Deverell’s newest book I”ll See You in My Dreams. I’m now in the middle of it, and for those of us who like legal thrillers, it is quite good. It’s interesting, well-written, is full of eccentric characters, has a compelling story and is full of wit. It’s no wonder that Deverell is one of Canada’s top crime fiction writers.

    • thanks, Kathy, I’ve only read the first so far but may jump a few….there is only so much time……

  4. I would pick up this book to read for 2 reasons. Firstly the London location which I always enjoy reading about, and secondly because of the title. I like it immediately. I have a huge amount of books to read at the moment but I won’t forget about this one.

    • Yes, the location is well done. I seem to have read several books about the same location in quick succession, so I must find a bit of geographical variation!

  5. Pingback: Crossbones Yard by Kate Rhodes | Petrona Book Reviews archive

  6. Pingback: June reading report and book of the month | Petrona

  7. Pingback: Best new-to-me authors in 2012 #2 | Petrona

Comments are closed.