Book review: Lucifer’s Tears by James Thompson

Lucifer’s Tears
by James Thompson
Harper Collins (Avon), 2011

“Finland. The ninth and innermost circle of hell. A frozen lake of blood and guilt formed from Lucifer’s tears, turned to ice by the flapping of his leathery wings.” Inspector Kari Vaara muses on his homeland as he is about to embark on the night shift in Helsinki’s homicide division. He thinks back to events last year (described in Snow Angels, the first book in this series), in which he solved a series of crimes while based in Lapland in the far north, but at some personal cost, resulting in his transfer to Helsinki at his wife Kate’s request. Kate is manager of a large hotel and about to have the couple’s first child. She’s American; her brother and sister are due to come and stay to help her after the baby is born.

Vaara is not very happy about living in Helsinki or the imminent arrival of his in-laws, but is soon plunged into a series of crime investigations, as well as being assigned a new partner, Milo, who is a bit of a psychopath as well as being formidably intelligent so can crack any code and analyse blood-spatter patterns without the need for a computer program. The main crime that the two encounter, and that forms the backbone of the book, is one in which a young woman has been horribly tortured and killed while visiting her riding-instructor lover. Vaara’s boss is convinced the lover is responsible for the death, but Vaara is less sure, as there is no apparent motive. Instead, he begins to investigate the woman’s husband, a rich businessman, and his secretary, who bears an uncanny resemblance to the victim.

The pace never lets up. Other cases that Vaara is working on include an investigation into a possible cover-up of Finnish atrocities towards the Jews in World War II; the death of a drinker in a bar when a couple of over-eager bouncers throw him out; and another drunk man who is threatening the young pupils at a school. In each case, Vaara provides us with a potted history of the background: for example, when he is called out to the school shooting, the reader is told how many previous such events there have been in Finland, when they happened, who was the perpetrator and what was the outcome. This style of writing is forgiveable so long as it is kept brief, but it becomes very laboured during the WW2 plot, possibly because of the complexity of Finland-Russia-Germany geopolitical relationships and the number of times everyone changed sides within and outside the country. Basically, there is enough material here for a book in its own right about these possible Finnish WW2 crimes; trying to cram it all in here with several other plots made it all too superficial and unengaging.

As well as Vaara’s action-packed job (I’ve only touched on the many storylines in this review, some of which are extremely crudely described), he has to deal with the relatives from hell and with a permanent headache. He’s seeing a therapist who explores some possible reasons for Vaara’s suffering, based on events in his past which seem to have been set aside for a future book. Later on, Vaara turns out to have several brothers, one of whom is a neurologist (!). This brother arranges for some tests to see if the headaches have a physical cause. A final theme running through the book is the relationship between Vaara and his wife Kate – the two are very much in love but find it hard to confide in each other. The imminent arrival of the baby exacerbates their anxiety and desire to “not let down” the other.

Lucifer’s Tears is a very busy book, and despite its crude, up-front language and failure to shy from any gory details, is enjoyably readable. I have to say that the plot creaks quite a bit, though – the outcome of the main murder case is not only resolved in a rather stupid fashion, but it leaves Vaara set up in a heavily signalled new role for the future, with a couple of cardboard cut-out helpers with particular skills. Vaara and Kate are left on the brink in their personal lives in the final chapter, also – all is up for grabs for the next book. I still haven’t decided whether I’ll read it or not. On the plus side are the Finland setting and the brisk, no-nonsense pace. On the minus side are the clunky prose, the plot (each situation as it arises has a predictable outcome, as well as everything just falling into Vaara’s lap), and the author’s didactic style of interjecting a Finnish history or geography lesson at every available opportunity, in a somewhat aggressive manner that brooks no argument from the reader!

I bought this book as a Christmas present to myself. On the back cover is written “perfect for fans of Stieg Larsson and Jo Nesbo” – which, together with the front-cover sticker “the next big thing in Nordic crime” and endorsement from Michael Connelly, is covering all the bases ;-). [Update: of course, the author has nothing to do with the cover or wording the publisher chooses.]

Other reviews of Lucifer’s Tears: The Mystery Reader, Material Witness, Nordic Bookblog, Killer Reads and Murder by Type.

My review of Snow Angels, the first in this series (Lucifer’s Tears is the second).

Interview with the author at Scandinavian Crime Fiction blog. In a reversal of the book’s plot, James Thompson is an American who married a Finn and now lives in Finland (hence the novel is not originally written in Finnish, yet provides an authentic setting).

13 thoughts on “Book review: Lucifer’s Tears by James Thompson

  1. unlike you I still have a TBR pile of over a hundred books and this one has been on it for 6 months or so. Must get around to it before the third one comes out which is due soon I think.

  2. I may read this. This is encouraging. However, I wasn’t too pleased with the author’s first book. I found some political/factual errors in the book which I emailed the author about.
    I’d like to know more about the Finnish/Soviet/German intrigues during WWII, but there are other ways to do this, I’m sure. Clunky prose, I don’t know. I’ll see how my reading year is going.
    I’m never at a loss for Nordic noir but I’ll have to wait on this one.

  3. I quite fancy this one Maxine. However I am becoming increasingly by labels such as ‘the next Jo Nesbo’ etc. I’m reading Camilla Ceder at the moment, billed as ‘the female Steig Larsson’. I’m enjoying it but the comparison is rubbish.

    • Oh yes, I agree, Sarah – Camilla Ceder is from the “other line” of Swedish crime fiction, the more psychological novel of the type written by Johan Theorin or Asa Larsson. I hope you enjoy her, though, I liked her debut a lot.

  4. Maxine, I have to say that I was very glad of the encouragement to read Until Thy Wrath Be Past. Though I am leery of supernatural elements, it was fine in this book, to my surprise — in a good way.
    There never seems to be a dearth of Nordic crime fiction. It’s finding the good ones that matters.
    I don’t have patience for mediocre any more. So glad to read honest reviews, such as those posted here.

    • Thanks, Kathy. I try to give an honest evaluation while realising that my cup of tea (or not) might not be everyone’s. There is so much Nordic fiction being translated now that some of it is bound not to be so good….however this one is not translated.

  5. Maxine – An excellent review as ever! I did have to laugh at your mention of those stickers and endorsements :-). As I was reading your post I was thinking about what a tricky balance it is to give background information without overdoing it. I think that’s always a tough decision for the author. The Finnish setting interests me a lot but maybe I’ll wait on this just for a bit. My TBR list is long enough for now. Still, I’m glad you enjoyed it.

  6. Dear Maxine, It’s usually unseemly for an author to respond to a review, but I think that only applies to whining. I’m contemplating an essay on reviewing and found this one. I enjoy your reviews, including the above of my work.. Few reviewers are as both even-handed and thoughtful as I have found yours to be. I would like to point out to readers that although some publishers are kind enough to ask authors their opinions about cover art, we have no say in them–comparisons to Larsson or stickers, etc.–or even in the titles our foreign publishers choose to give them. They’re required only to produce a faithful rendition of the work, and of course, that’s quite subjective. Thanks for taking the time to review Lucifer’s Tears.
    Best, James

    • Thank you for your generous comment, James. Yes you are of course quite correct that authors have nothing to do with cover art/words, and I should have made that clearer in my review. Apologies.

  7. Pingback: Lucifer’s Tears by James Thompson | Petrona Book Reviews archive

  8. Pingback: January reading report | Petrona

Comments are closed.