Book Review: Hidden Depths by Ann Cleeves

Hidden Depths

Ann Cleeves

Pan, 2007

Hidden Depths is a classic crime-fiction story set in the small towns and villages of Northumberland (and, a bit, in the city of Newcastle-upon-Tyne), north-east England. Inspector Vera Stanhope and her team are called out when a young teenager, Luke Armstrong, is found dead in his bath by his mother, Julie. Julie at first assumes the boy, who had learning difficulties, had committed suicide, but Vera and team quickly establish that he had been murdered. Soon after, the body of another young person, this time a woman called Lily Marsh, is found on the beach, having died in a similar fashion to Luke. Again, Vera’s team investigates.

The former case, that of Luke, has proved hard to tackle for the police due to a dearth of suspects, though Vera quickly picks up on the fact that Luke’s best friend Tom had drowned some time ago, and that although the death was accidental, Luke tried to save Tom and has since blamed himself for his friend’s death. Tom comes from a family of criminals, so Vera visits his father in prison and uncovers a couple of clues, or rather hints.

The second case, that of Lily, presents a richer crew of suspects. Lily is discovered by four men who are celebrating the sixtieth birthday of one of them, unpleasant Peter Calvert, a botanist. Calvert, in common with Cleeves characters in other novels, is both an obsessive birdwatcher and a failed yet pompous academic. Although he is a university lecturer, he has not reached what he considers to be his full potential, and has to suffer the indignity of having research papers rejected from journals, and so on. His smug wife Felicity is much younger than him. She does not work outside the home, spending her time looking after the couple’s youngest child James, cooking and keeping the house and garden beautiful. She enjoys flirting with her husband’s birdwatching friends Gary, a sound technician, Sam, a librarian and writer, and Clive, a museum curator.

Vera and her team search for a link between the two cases. Soon they find that they have almost too many connections, as more characters turn up who have or could have intersected with both victims. The charm and heart of this novel is the personality of Vera. She’s much more central here than she was in Telling Tales, her previous outing, so we learn a bit more about her background and relationship with her father, as well as her investigative methods and attitudes, and her relationship with younger policeman Joe Ashworth. Vera is not the kind of detective, nor Cleeves the kind of author, who is big on procedure and documentation. Rather, Vera goes to see all the characters in turn, gradually digging under their defences and working out how their past or present secrets might be relevant. Whether or not this approach is a realistic depiction of police-work, the result is a compelling, sympathetic and insightful account of the quietly desperate lives led by some people, on the edge of mental illness in some cases, and how they struggle to keep going in a hostile or indifferent world. The character studies here are acute, and while there are so many clues and connections that the solution to the mysteries does have an element of “select any person out of the list of suspects” about it, the novel as a whole is readable, absorbing and enjoyable.

My copy of this book was a gift from the publisher.

There are three books in the Vera Stanhope series: The Crow Trap, Telling Tales and Hidden Depths (links go to my reviews). The next installment, Silent Voices, is out in the UK early next year. Vera will also be a TV character early next year (UK), in which Hidden Depths is currently planned to be the first episode even though it is the third in the book series.

Among her other books, Ann Cleeves is the author of a Shetland Quartet. My reviews of these novels can be read at Euro Crime.

Read other reviews of Hidden Depths at: Euro Crime (Sunnie Gill), Musings from a Muddy Island (Juliet Doyle), Spinetingler magazine (Martin Edwards) and DJ’s Krimiblog (Dorte Jakobsen).

5 thoughts on “Book Review: Hidden Depths by Ann Cleeves

  1. Dorte H said…
    Thank you for the link.

    I really enjoyed your review; though it is not much more than a year ago that I read this one, I have already forgotten most of it. I think the environment of the Shetland quartet is more interesting, but Vera Stanhope is a great favourite of mine. It is good to know that a new Stanhope is on its way.

    Reply 21 November 2010 at 18:43

    Margot Kinberg said…
    Maxine – Thanks so much for this excellent review🙂. As I’m sure you know, I like Vera Stanhope, so I’m glad that you liked this one. You make an interesting point about the number of suspects, and that can, indeed, be an issue in a novel. Still, as you say, it’s the character studies that can make a novel work, and it can be very engaging to focus on the lives of people who are trying to cope in a negative environment.

    Reply 21 November 2010 at 19:22

    Bernadette said…
    This is the only Vera Stanhope book I have read and it prompted me to start reading the shetland quartet. I’ll definitely be looking to read the new one.

    Reply 21 November 2010 at 21:35

    Jose Ignacio said…
    I presume I will read the Vera Stanhope books once I finish reading the Shetland Quartet.

    Reply 21 November 2010 at 22:05

    kdurkin@earthlink.net said…
    An fyi: “Through the Cracks,” by Barbara Fister (who runs the terrific “Scandinavian Crime Fiction website/blog) is a good read–Chicago, issues of violence against women, the criminal justice system, immigration, plus a great woman detective and wit make for an interesting, fun and thought-provoking read. All good.

    Reply 24 November 2010 at 23:55

    Maxine said…
    Thanks, Kathy, I have read and enjoyed her first novel, along similar lines from your description: http://petrona.typepad.com/reviews/2010/06/in-the-wind-by-barbara-fister.html and I have another one of hers on my shelf to read (not sure if it is Through the Cracks or another.)

    Reply 25 November 2010 at 12:03

    kdurkin@earthlink.net said…
    I think you had said that one can read any of the Vera Stanhope books on its own without reading the first ones in the series (as opposed the Shetland Quartet which should be read in order). Is this correct?

    Reply 26 November 2010 at 02:51

    Maxine said…
    That is absolutely correct, Kathy.

    Reply 26 November 2010 at 11:08

    kdurkin@earthlink.net said…
    Since my library sadly doesn’t have enough global crime fiction, including British, there are no Vera Stanhope novels by Ann Cleeves, only a few of the Shetland Quartets, so I will be forced to turn to Amazon or the Book Depository. Can you recommend which one to choose, since this is an investment? The character sounds so interesting from the Ann Cleeves’ website, in a discussion of the tv series being made about Vera Stanhope.

    Reply 26 November 2010 at 14:07

  2. I would start either with Raven Black (first of the Shetland quartet) or The Crow Trap (the first Vera). Both are good. The Crow Trap is long, though – but you get some of Vera’s back story in it.

  3. Pingback: What’s in a name challenge, old and new year | Petrona

  4. Pingback: Vera Stanhope and Jimmy Perez, books by Ann Cleeves | Petrona

  5. Pingback: Hidden Depths by Ann Cleeves | Petrona Book Reviews archive

Comments are closed.