Where are all the women?

Do you need a Y chromosome to be taken seriously as a crime writer” So asks Natasha Cooper in the Times last Friday (11 July)as she prepares for this year’s Theakston Old Peculier Crime Writing Festival in Harrogate, where she is chair of the panel of shortlisted authors for the Crime Novel of the Year award. She goes on to write: “The shortlisted authors are terrific, several of them are friends of mine, and they all deserve their places on the list. But why is Stef Penney the only woman? Perhaps I shouldn’t be surprised. The problem is not confined to any one shortlist. When this newspaper published The 50 Greatest Crime Writers in April, only 13 were women.” I’m glad to see that Natasha makes the exact point that occurred to me when I saw the winner. Yes it was a woman (Patricia Highsmith), but she was pictured naked to the waist. Natasha makes some excellent points in her article, and speculates about why this imbalance has come about.
The issue of woman writers is familiar to readers of this blog, as we had a debate on this very topic in response to a top ten list of great crime-fiction writers that featured no women. We came up with a list of ten favourite women writers, but many more than that were suggested, and are listed in that post. In defence of Theakston’s Old Peculier, I would say that there were more women on the long list, and the short list was created from readers’ votes on that long list. (I voted for a book by a woman that did not make it to the short list.) The recently announced 2008 Dagger awards featured two women winners out of a possible six categories: the Duncan Lawrie Dagger went to Frances Fyfield for Blood From Stone, and the International Duncan Lawrie Dagger to Dominique Manotti for Lorraine Connection, (translated from the French by Amanda Hopkinson and Ros Schwartz). Two out of four of the “highly commendeds” were women. By the way, you can see who I and other Euro Crime reviewers and fans nominated for our shortlists for the International Dagger here.

Well, it is something to ponder on as I go to Harrogate.

4 thoughts on “Where are all the women?

  1. Just wanted to sing the praises of the Ampersand Agency’s excellent crime writers, a number of whom are flying the flag for womankind as well as crime fiction in general:-
    Helen Black, Tracy Gilpin, S.J. Bolton…
    And regarding S.J…., I would say that maybe a Y chromosome isn’t compulsory, but a sprinkling other enigmatic (gender neutral) initials can help…? à la J.K.Rowling?
    &… xxx

  2. Having the winner in the “main categories” of this year’s Edgars, Daggers, Agathas and Hammett in mind one starts to wonder (at least as a man) if this is not a question of female oversensitivity syndrome (FOS).
    Therefore I looked at the nominees of the different awards and categories and have to confess that it is more than FOS. The percentage of female nominees varies tremendously between awards and categories, but more often than not the number of female nominees is lower than average. And not everything is explained by subgenres.
    [You had recently a post about the responsibility to trackback. Not only that your blog-provider did not accept my trackback, it does not allow links, either. A pity. Perhaps someone would have been interested in the data].

  3. That’s bizarre about the trackbacks, krimileser, it is certainly set up to accept them. I’ll take another look, but I do occasionally get them. (Usually spam I have to say, but I think trackbacks are good in principle.)

  4. I think it is a general “incompatibility” between providers. Yours and WordPress, Peter Rozovsky’s and wordpress ? No way.

Comments are closed.