Betrayal, by Paul Carson

My review of Paul Carson’s Betrayal is posted on Eurocrime. I’m also posting the review below, but do check out the Eurocrime site for an excellent reading guide and resource.

Carson, Paul – ‘Betrayal’
Paperback: 464 pages (Jul. 2006) Publisher: Arrow ISBN: 0099469294

Paul Carson’s first two Dublin-based books, SCALPEL and COLD STEEL, were fast-paced hospital-based thrillers in the style of Robin Cook or Michael Palmer. I have not read his next two but his fifth, BETRAYAL, continues the medical, thriller and Irish themes, this time at Harmon Penitentiary, "Europe’s most dangerous jail".

The central character, Frank Ryan, is the prison’s chief medical officer. At the start of the book, he is called out late at night to attend a patient. On arrival, all is silent and in darkness. Ryan is attacked, severely beaten up, and wakes up later in what appears to be a hospital. Nobody will tell him why he is there, or even where he is, for some days. Eventually he finds out he is in England, his injuries apparently the result of a drunken brawl for which he is in trouble with the police. He’s shipped back to Dublin in disgrace: not only is his job on the line, but his impossibly beautiful girlfriend Lisa has vanished as if she has never been.

The rest of the book concerns Ryan’s attempts to find out what is going on. Lots of disparate elements are introduced: a corrupt Irish justice ministry, a corrupt prison administration (including Ryan’s boss), a corrupt police force and a corrupt, violent prison population, including a ganglord who forces Ryan to help him attempt to escape. As seems to be the current crime-fiction fashion, the Balkan conflict features at the heart of this excess of corruption, acting as the knot into which all the various ends are twisted.

Although this book is enjoyable enough, it is hard to care too much about whether Ryan comes through it all. The characters are mechanical, events implausible or illogical, the various motivating factors less than persuasive, and there are too many cliches (the disappearing "perfect" girlfriend subplot the most predictable of these, but there are others). The occasional passages containing medical details are the most convincing parts of the book, as one might expect given that the author is a doctor. The final resolution is hasty and superficial, but by this point in the book I didn’t have high expectations so it was not too much of a let-down.

Although it is hard to credit the words "The international number one bestseller" above the author’s name and title on the cover, the book certainly is a rattling good read if you are prepared to suspend belief. It is also a quick one: it will take only an hour or two. But don’t expect depth or reflection: what you’ll get is escapist, lightweight action that does not bear too much scrutiny.

4 thoughts on “Betrayal, by Paul Carson

  1. Very nice site, Eurocrime! I’m half tempted to toss my bonnet in the ring for some of those free copies of books they’re handing out but can’t quite get myself to. Maybe I’ll cave in yet, you never know…
    Suspending disbelief is something one has to do all too often with contemporary fiction. I can feel your angst on that one.

  2. Hi Bluestalking reader. Please do enter the competitions :-). They change monthly and the current ones are open to everyone. Next month’s will be a bit more fiddly as some will be for UK residents, some US etc. It’ll also include DVDs of Wire in The Blood for US residents!!

  3. There was a time when I enjoyed medical thrillers. During that time I read a couple of Carson’s, but soon gave up. I found them lightweight, so I can understand your comments.
    Reasonable reading if you want to be distracted by a fast paced thriller and not intellectually challenged, though. And I’m not being a bitch here. There’s a time and a place for everything; sometimes that’s all we look for, especially when it comes to distraction reading.

Comments are closed.